Being ready to conduct an organization-wide survey like Guarding Minds at Work effectively includes making the business case, getting buy-in from all involved, communicating your plan, and choosing your approach. Doing this well helps you set your organization up to successfully address and improve psychological health and safety while maintaining performance and productivity.
“Rushing to survey” describes organizations that ask employees for feedback before they are prepared to respond to what they learn. Before sending the survey link, develop a clear plan for reviewing the results, engaging employees and taking action. Acting promptly after the survey closes, even before you have completed final analysis, builds on the momentum and helps prevent employee skepticism that can arise when feedback appears to lead nowhere. This prompt action can be as simple as:
- Launching an already-planned initiative aimed at improving psychological health and safety on the day after the survey closes
- Sending a follow-up email highlighting one preliminary finding and a related practical action you will take right away. This demonstrates progress while you continue analyzing and planning how to address more complex issues.
- Subscribing to a free email seriesOpens a new website in a new windowOpens a new website in a new window about work-life balance or leadership or mental health and sharing the emails with relevant employees.
Organizational readiness
Consider organizational readiness for change. If there is no appetite or capacity for meaningful change, seeking employee feedback through a survey when you cannot act on the results may not be ideal. There may be internal or external factors that make taking action more difficult, such as:
- Potential mergers or major reorganizations. Where there will be an increase in hiring and orientation, you can consider strategies that are more likely to set up new candidates for sustainable success.
- Current labour disputes or pending strike actions. These may not be the ideal times to begin a process in which management and the union are supported to work together in a way that is psychologically safer.
- Impending business issues such as shutdowns, layoffs, terminations or redeployments. It may make sense to focus first on limiting the risk related to the impact of these issues. Termination and layoff planning could help.
- External events impacting the organization, especially where there’s a lot of uncertainty, fear or sadness. This may be an ideal time to address the most pressing needs related to the uncertainty.
Any of the above may make it difficult for large-scale change in the moment. This shouldn't prevent the work environment modifying the processes involved to ensure they are less likely to cause psychological harm and supporting employees through difficult changes. These changes can include grief at the loss of co-workers or increased workload pressures. Identify what could be helpful and narrow your focus to making incremental positive changes.
For inspiration, consider completing the Organizational review, a collaborative approach that can be done with or without the employee survey to create an action plan.
Work together with your health and safety committee
The Health and Safety Committee (HSC) is a fundamental component of most medium to large companies’ internal responsibility system and is uniquely positioned to work together with others to champion psychological health and safety in the workplace. Working with your health and safety committee is a core part of your legislated mandate to identify, assess, and recommend controls for all workplace hazards, including psychosocial hazards, in all Canadian jurisdictions.
Before the organization "rushes to survey," ensure your HSC participation is clear, joint, and supported.
- Secure joint commitment - The HSC should formally request a written commitment from both labour and management that PHS will be treated as a serious health and safety matter, in line with your legislative duties.
- Establish a role - Agree on the HSC's specific role in the process—it is best suited to participate in the Assessment, Analysis, and Action Planning stages.
- Communicate as a committee - Use the HSC's neutral position to communicate the survey's purpose to employees: it is a hazard identification tool, not a diagnostic test, and results will be used to make the workplace safer. This builds trust and encourages honest participation.
- Allocate time and resources - Ensure the committee is granted adequate paid time to participate in all stages of the PHS initiative, including training to understand the survey tool and the nature of psychosocial hazards.
Working together, the HSC helps ensure the PHS initiative is viewed as a shared responsibility and a serious occupational health measure, leading to more successful and sustainable outcomes.
Getting buy-in
In addition to your health and safety committee, it’s important to get buy-in and commitment from everyone in the workplace who has or will have some role or responsibility for psychological health and safety (PHS). Without this prior approval, the process can be halted by concerned leaders in management or union if applicable. This may be because they aren’t clear on the risks and benefits and are focused on other priorities.
Either human resources or the health and safety committee should formally request a written commitment from both labour and management that PHS will be treated as a serious health and safety matter, in line with their legislative duties.
The purpose of getting buy-in is to establish that PHS is a priority to your organization and to get written Commitment, leadership and participation for psychological health and safety (labour and management) in the form of a directive or policy statement.
Be prepared to respond to questions from senior leaders in management or labour about the:
- Costs and benefits of assessing PHS
- Estimated time and effort that’ll be required
- Structure that’ll support implementing your plan
- Need for employee and leader time during and after the process
- Management of employee expectations for change
Each of the following can help you do this.
Costs and benefits
Beginning a dialogue with leaders and employees about how psychosocial factors impact work may result in positive changes, even without a formal implementation process. Larger initiatives and programs aren’t always required.
- The economic and social benefits of a psychologically healthy and safe environment can include sustainability of an engaged workforce and a healthy bottom line. Psychological health and safety statistics are available to provide evidence.
- Considering the costs can help you use your own data to make the business case for addressing PHS.
- A strengths and weaknesses, opportunities and threats (SWOT) analysis can be a useful tool for decision-making. Free information for conducting a SWOT analysis is provided courtesy of BusinessBalls Free Work and Life LearningOpens a new website in a new windowOpens a new website in a new window .
- Consider having leaders complete the Psychologically Safe Leader Assessment (PSLA). This helps identify specific leadership strategies that support psychological health and safety.
The Deloitte Insights report¹ shows that mental health programs running for up to three years had a median yearly return on investment (ROI) of $1.62 for every dollar invested. Programs running for over three years had an ROI of $2.18.
Time and effort
Estimate the time and effort required to do the assessment, analyze results and implement change. The size and scope of your plan will be relative to the complexity of your organization and the initiatives you choose to implement. Some organizations might survey and implement limited changes once a year. Others will create a continual improvement process.
If your HSC has not yet formally addressed PHS or psychosocial hazards, start by integrating this lens into your existing duties to help build your business case:
Workplace inspections
PHS integration: Look for psychosocial hazards, not just physical risks. Are work areas excessively noisy, isolating, or overcrowded? Are employees taking their breaks? Review actions and responses to help with Psychosocial hazard mitigation.
Incident/accident investigations
PHS integration: Ask questions about psychosocial factors. Did workload, lack of clarity, or harassment contribute to a physical injury, near-miss, or stress-related absence?
Worker complaints
PHS integration: Ensure a confidential and effective process for worker complaints related to harassment, bullying, and psychological distress, treating them with the same urgency as a physical hazard.
Estimate the time your organization may need to complete the following tasks:
- Developing the business case, including baseline measurements.
- Securing commitment from top leadership from both labour and management.
- Creating a communication plan that addresses any potential concerns.
- Setting up the survey process by choosing when and how it’ll happen, who’ll participate and what’ll be included from among the options.
- Administering the Guarding Minds at Work survey. This is probably the easiest part.
- Analyzing the Guarding Minds at Work results.
- Communicating results, celebrating successes, and identifying areas for improvement.
- Engaging the workforce in proposing action plans. This participation is critical to success.
- Engaging a working group, which includes representatives from your health and safety committee, in implementing the plans that could eventually become part of a day-to-day routine.
- Measuring outcomes. Did the plans achieve the goals that were set?
- Taking corrective action. This includes modifications or new approaches as indicated by the evaluation of outcomes.
- Establishing a process of continual improvement. Consider re-administering the survey every couple of years.
- Estimating ongoing time allocation. For example, you may choose one hour per team every two weeks to maintain the improvements in PHS.
Demands on employees, health and safety committees and leaders
PHS done well supports employee productivity and a healthy bottom line. Organizations or departments may believe that they don’t have enough time or resources to invest in this. Like all health and safety approaches, you may wish to consider the following when discussing priorities:
- Organizations may begin by looking at just one psychosocial factor. Identify one or more which the health and safety committee and leaders believe is impacting success.
- One example is workload management. Effective workload management is rarely about doing less work. The focus should be on doing good work with less stress, pressure and distraction. This concept can open dialogue and help identify solutions. It can also reduce stress-related absenteeism, errors or accidents and help create an atmosphere for continued improvement.
- Leading-edge organizations conscientiously choose best practices for continual improvement. PHS can follow this approach. New approaches and evidence-based actions are being developed regularly.
- Comprehensive resources are provided in Psychological health and safety policy recommendations to help modify and improve existing policies and processes.
- Have leadership openly accept responsibility for the current situation and the need to make changes. This does not mean they need to accept blame. Accepting responsibility can reduce the need for others to justify or defend their current behaviours or positions. Consider and act on the results of the Psychologically Safe Leader Assessment or the Psychologically Safe Team Assessment.
- This can be an opportunity to engage staff in discussing ways to protect PHS at work. The On the agenda workshop series materials can help.
Engage external experts, if appropriate. Guarding Minds at Work is a free, self-serve resource, but some organizations prefer an external consultant to assist. Existing knowledge and expertise may reduce overall effort and time.
Serious employee considerations
- Risk management approaches are necessary when any part of your work environment could be considered poisoned or toxic. Put safeguards in place to help ensure no further harm’s done to employee psychological safety. Potential legal and ethical concerns provides a framework for prevention.
- Immediately address issues of trauma, violence, harassment, bullying or discrimination.
- Be sensitive to the current ability of those who are affected by trauma to complete the survey. They may require extra time or a quiet place without distractions.
- See also Impairment and addiction response for leaders, Grief response for leaders, Suicide response for leaders and Psychosis and how to help in a crisis for additional resources.
Manage employee expectations
There may be some concern that talking about PHS will create unreasonable expectations from employees.
- PHS is about optimizing employees’ focus and energy. This leads to improved productivity and performance. It’s about supporting every employee to do their best work.
- Some may worry that discussing PHS with employees will cause problems or invite unreasonable criticism. But avoiding or denying work issues may allow problems to worsen until they become a crisis or a risk-management concern.
- Proactively identifying and addressing PHS issues can help prevent time-consuming and morale-dampening situations. This also leads to a more effective plan for prevention.
- The Canadian Standards Association (CSA/ASC) z1003 - Psychological Health and Safety in the Workplace — Prevention, promotion, and guidance provides an evidence-based framework to support taking action and avoid risk to employee psychological safety.
Explore more information about Guarding Minds or begin using the survey tools.